• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Latest
November’s GST collection rises to over Rs 1.31 lakh cr

Online Gaming – A conundrum for GST

21/07/2022
CRPF man injured in Dec 24 Ganderbal grenade attack succumbs at SKIMS

Nowhatta Encounter: Injured cop succumbs at hospital

15/08/2022
Will make J&K most developed, top performer UT in country: LG

Days of fear, corruption and militancy are over: J&K L-G

15/08/2022
BSF, Pak Rangers exchange sweets at IB in Jammu

BSF, Pak Rangers exchange sweets at IB in Jammu

15/08/2022
India must be a developed nation in 25 years: PM Modi lists five pledges

India must be a developed nation in 25 years: PM Modi lists five pledges

15/08/2022
Dip In Active Covid-19 Cases  

2 Decisions For Youth, Employees

15/08/2022
India gears up to celebrate 75 years of Independence

India gears up to celebrate 75 years of Independence

15/08/2022

President wishes nation ahead of I-Day, mentions partition horrors

15/08/2022

LG Sinha greets people on 75th  Independence Day

15/08/2022

PM, others pay tributes to victims of partition

15/08/2022

Security beefed up in J&K ahead of I-Day celebrations

15/08/2022

AC scraps SO- 192, brings all J&K Govt employees on equal-footing

15/08/2022

Extends ex-gratia of Rs 25 lakhs  to DDC members

15/08/2022

LG joins walkathon to celebrate Har Ghar Tiranga Utsav in Srinagar

15/08/2022

LG launches 2nd phase of Skill Development Training Program for women, youth in BFSI sector

15/08/2022

SPIC MACAY delegation calls on LG Sinha

15/08/2022
  • Home
  • Front
  • Jammu & Kashmir
    • City
  • Anchor stories
  • Business
  • Sports
  • National
  • World
  • Opinion
    • Edit
    • Interviews
    • Letters
  • epaper
Tuesday, August 16, 2022
PRECIOUS KASHMIR
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Front
  • Jammu & Kashmir
    • City
  • Anchor stories
  • Business
  • Sports
  • National
  • World
  • Opinion
    • Edit
    • Interviews
    • Letters
  • epaper
Precious Kashmir
No Result
View All Result
Home Oped Opinion

Online Gaming – A conundrum for GST

Indo Asian News Service by Indo Asian News Service
21/07/2022
in Opinion
4 min read
November’s GST collection rises to over Rs 1.31 lakh cr
FacebookTwitterWhatsappEmail

By: S.K. Reddy

One of the biggest challenges facing the Governments today is the rapid evolving nature of the digital economy, with which the regulators are struggling to keep pace.

In fact, the challenge posed by technology enabled services means that even if one or few countries devise regulations, businesses can simply shift to another jurisdiction where the regulations are more convenient to them. Yet, lack of any regulation can play havoc.

The crypto meltdown and the consequent freezing of transactions by some platforms is one such telling case. The rapidly evolving but unregulated product offerings left millions exposed to a 70 per cent to 100 per cent erosion of value and wiped out of life-time savings for some.

Online gaming industry is posing quite a similar challenge to regulators. Globally, the industry caters to over two billion entertainment seeking consumers, with services being provided by a rapidly growing multi-billion dollar industry. For example, data released by the Entertainment Software Association (ESA) and The NPD Group, in the US, shows the overall consumer spending on video games was US Dollars 60.4 billion in 2021, an 8 per cent increase over 2020.

This figure includes revenues from all content categories, including hardware, subscription spending across console, cloud, mobile, portable, PC and VR platforms. Microsoft announced a buy-out of the US based Activision Blizzard, for a whopping sum of US dollars 70 billion. While Activision Blizzard is highly profitable clocking annual revenue of 8.8 billion and profits of US dollars 2.7 billion, even Roblox, a cash-burning gaming company, boasts of market cap of close to US dollars 24 billion. Roblox offers 20 million games with an average of 32.6 million people a day logging in, as per a report published on Bloomberg. The company has also plunged into metaverse with Supermodel Karlie Kloss, the latest celebrity to onboard.

The All-India Gaming Federation, which claims to be the apex industry body for self-regulation for online gaming in India comprises 70 online gaming companies and claims a combined user base of 4.5 crore. As per their projections, India’s industry is poised to hit 30,000 crore of revenue by 2025. Reportedly, investments in the industry are growing rapidly with Rs 17,500 crore having been invested. There are host of other small and micro IT enterprises involved in gaming. Financial Express (29.6.22) has reported that there are over 950 online gaming companies in India. Several companies are single entrepreneurs,offering games developed by them on Google’s play store and Apple’s App store. Most of these games are free to download, though the consumer could be at risk of being bombarded with unsolicited advertisements, at times lewd, or even worse, near-hacked.

Paid games are available at a one-time or monthly subscription fee. There are more complex pricing models too involving purchase of in-game credits. And then there is competitive online gaming, such as, chess.com which is reported to have a subscriber base of 57 million with over 400,00 online players at any point of time.Online games include card games (bridge, rummy, poker) to roulette to boxing to war games. Readers will recall the rage created by the game PUBG developed by the Chinese mega-company – Tencents.

According to Tencent games, there were almost 175 million pubg mobile users in India and they claimed having 1.5 crore daily users.The most eye – popping story is that of Dota 2 which is played with teams from around the world. There are professional leagues and tournaments – an event format known as the Dota Pro Circuit. The International tournament is crowdfunded with prize money reaching upwards of US$40 million, making Dota 2 the most lucrative e-sport in the world.

The Government of India has set up a Committee of Secretaries for considering regulations for the online gaming industry. This move is well timed. India will do well to position a National Gaming Commission under the Ministry of Home Affairs, as an apex and appellate body on the lines of GST Council, while the states could similarly structure State Gaming Commissions.

Most developed countries have Gaming Commissions and elaborate gaming laws. These bodies are currently seized with vexing problems such as underage gambling & addiction. In a report published on Bloomberg on June 29, 2022, it was said that the UK was considering capping stakes between British Pound 2 to 5 for online casinos and a ban on free bets, while updating its 17-year-old gambling legislation. There is also a proposal to obligate online casinos to implement “affordability checks” to show how much, a user can safely spend. China has even gone a step ahead. Online games require regulatory approval before they can be launched. After a hiatus of nine months, Chinese Regulators approved new online games in April 2022. Approvals had been paused over concerns of children being addicted or conformity with Communist party values.

A Group of Ministers (GoM), chaired by Hon’ble Chief Minister Sangma, a Wharton Alumni, is looking at a taxation regime for casinos, online games and horse racing. Media is rife with reports of 28 per cent tax being imposed on online gaming. The industry is up in arms against the reported recommendation of GoMon the ground that it would kill a nascent technology industry. It is said that business will move underground or to other jurisdictions posing implementation challenges to regulators, whether under OIDAR (GST law for overseas service providers to pay tax for services rendered to individuals in India) or for purposes of equalization levy under Income Tax.

The task before GoM is by no measure easy. Rapidly evolving technology, immense subscriber bases and huge revenues have made online gaming, a heady high stakes mix of entertainment and gambling. From intellectually stimulating games like crosswords to “parimatch” (Tagline: “Play online win real cash”) from a Cyprus registered and Ukraine origin gaming company dot the landscape. The rapidly morphing gaming scenario poses a nightmare for any tax administration. How to monitor when a game creates a pot of money to collect for a winner (“actionable claim”) or when a player is simply spending time and money entertaining himself in a competitive e-sport is an issue. Then there are parity considerations, such as the Casino owners citing the case of online casinos and card games for a reduction in taxes.

While the online gaming industry makes much of the concept of “skill vs chance”, which emerged out of the SC Judgements in the case of Sunrise Associates (2006) and Skill Lotto (2020), the argument is quite specious in the present technological landscape.

Dividing lines have become blurred due to features contained within games which make such classification a very difficult task. Basically, the guidance post could be prize money (actionable claim) and a differentiation made between user-pays but gets nothing except entertainment versus a pot of winnings, should determine tax rates. No doubt this poses a challenging task for the tax administration but it is time for building capacity and self-regulation to manage present day complexities of the digital economy. Whichever way the Council decides, it would be tragic if administrative convenience of GST officers alone makes the case to decide the rate of taxation.

(S.K. Reddy, IRS. The author is a retired Commissioner.)

(IANS)

Share196Tweet123SendSend
Indo Asian News Service

Indo Asian News Service

LATEST UPDATES

Nowhatta Encounter: Injured cop succumbs at hospital

Precious Kashmir 15/08/2022

Days of fear, corruption and militancy are over: J&K L-G

Indo Asian News Service 15/08/2022

BSF, Pak Rangers exchange sweets at IB in Jammu

Indo Asian News Service 15/08/2022

India must be a developed nation in 25 years: PM Modi lists five pledges

Indo Asian News Service 15/08/2022

Militant, policeman injured in Nowhatta encounter: Police

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

Gunfight breaks out in Sujan Rajouri

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

LG Sinha joins Walkathon to celebrate ‘Har Ghar Tiranga Utsav’ in Srinagar 

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

Government scraps SO- 192, brings all government employees in the UT on equal-footing in terms of salary, other benefits

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

Amid Forecast For Widespread Rains From Tomorrow, Minimum Temp Increases In J&K

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

Cop injured in Kulgam grenade attack succumbs: Police

Precious Kashmir 14/08/2022

CBI arrests revenue official for demanding, accepting bribe in Jammu

Precious Kashmir 13/08/2022

Shah Faesal appointed Deputy Secretary in Tourism Ministry

Indo Asian News Service 13/08/2022

Bitta Karate’s wife, Salahuddin’s son among four sacked on ‘anti-national charges’

Precious Kashmir 13/08/2022

Dry weather with partly cloudy sky likely in J&K

Indo Asian News Service 13/08/2022

Man dies After Falling From Under Construction House In Pahalgam

Precious Kashmir 13/08/2022

3.65 lakh pilgrims visited holy cave of Amarnath shrine this year: J&K LG Manoj Sinha

Precious Kashmir 12/08/2022

Cop Shot At, Injured in Bijbhera, shifted to hospital

Precious Kashmir 12/08/2022

Cyber Police Lodges Case Against Social-media Users for ‘Live Transmission of Explicit Content’

Precious Kashmir 12/08/2022

Committee asked to recommend measures against referrals from public to private hospitals by doctors

Precious Kashmir 12/08/2022

Kupwara: Flash floods cause widespread damage to agricultural fields in Lolab

Precious Kashmir 12/08/2022

Light/moderate rain likely in J&K

Indo Asian News Service 12/08/2022

Non local labourer shot dead in Bandipora

United News Of India 12/08/2022

Referrals of patients from Public to Pvt hospitals: Govt constitutes committee to conduct in-depth inquiry

Precious Kashmir 11/08/2022

Govt abolishes oral test, interview for various posts of level-6

Precious Kashmir 11/08/2022

Mother-daughter duo feared dead as flash floods hit Ramban

Precious Kashmir 11/08/2022
Precious Kashmir

Copyright © 2020 Precious Kashmir.

Navigate Site

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Terms of Service

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Front
  • Jammu & Kashmir
    • City
  • Anchor stories
  • Business
  • Sports
  • National
  • World
  • Opinion
    • Edit
    • Interviews
    • Letters
  • epaper

Copyright © 2020 Precious Kashmir.